When speaking with locals during the transition, it was clear what the community hoped: “that it would remain a true town bar.” With that in mind, the vision was simple—“Let’s open up a place where people can hang out.”

Today, Brickyard Tavern carries that legacy forward. Rooted in history, shaped by community, and built as a place to gather, it remains more than just a tavern—it’s part of Lafayette’s story.

Brickyard Tavern has long been a gathering place in Lafayette, New York. Previously known as the Countryside Inn and later Peggy’s, this building has welcomed generations of locals for food, conversation, and connection. The Countryside Inn was especially known for its Friday tradition of serving fresh haddock dinners!

The back room, where guests still gather today, holds a unique place in New York State history.

It was the last room in New York permitted for smoking, making it a memorable part of the building’s past and a frequent topic of local stories!

Much of the character inside reflects its local roots. The chandelier hanging in the tavern was sourced from Hall Funeral Home, and the bar itself is crafted from a mix of different woods found throughout New York State—each piece adding to the story of the space.

Come check out this original sign from when it was countryside inn hanging up in the tavern!